can a 44 magnum kill a grizzly bear can a 44 magnum kill a grizzly bear

MY HOG BACK UP IS MY SHORT BARREL S&W .44 THO HAVE YET HAVE ONE TO GET UP FROM REM .308 HOG HAMMERS. A good . Why dont you stay there. Anybody at all? The article was about pistols being used to defend against bears. Why wouldnt you choose a long-barreled gun that shoots with higher velocity, better penetration, more accuracy, less muzzle flip, less recoil, and holds one more bullet to stop a charging bear? Since grizzlies tend to be more aggressive than black bears, more problem encounters occur with grizzlies than other bear species. It isnt pleasant but I can shoot the 44 Magnum one-handed and manage a reasonable follow-up shot. When I test sprayed it, there was the slightest cross wind. . Biologically, grizzly bears are omnivores and will eat almost anything they come across. And if you want grownups to take you seriously, you really do have to stop sounding just like Jesse Pinkman. Please dont take out your rage on your wife or kids tonight. No it didn t. for grizzly protection. I digress..and of course firing in tandem at said target with the the other rounds by your partner. Most black bears can be stopped with a bullet fired from as close as 20 yards away, but brown and grizzly bears can be much more dangerous and may require shots from further distances. If you are carrying a handgun for self-protection against black bear, be sure to practice with it beforehand so that you are proficient in its use. Make sure youre familiar with your firearm and its capabilities. That which is asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence. 44 Magnum ammo should do the trick though! Dean Weingarten is a fear salesman, and not just in this article, but most of his others. Even sleeping! Global warming? As a wildcat cartridge, it hasnt seen the widespread use of other rounds on this list, but that hasnt stopped many guides and hunters, Nelson included, from converting Marlin lever guns for its very effective use. Would I be able to stop a bear attack if it happened to me? ALL ANIMALS UNPREDICTABLE, BEEN BUCKED OFF FOR NO APPARENT REASON BY MY USUALLY DOCILE AND FAITHFUL PINTO SEVERAL TIMES AND BITTEN BY MY SCOUT DOG IN NAM ONCE ON AMBUSH WHO REDEEMED HIMSELF BY SAVING MY LIFE THE NEXT AMBUSH. That same bullet in a .357 Magnum exits a four-inch barrel upwards of 1,400 fps. Want to feel fear for the right reasons? Every 1.5 pages, it tells you that youre now at the exact trail spot where yet another guy from yet another sawmill was killed by a grizzly on such and such a date. If I carried any handgun for self defense, Id only load it with one roundfor myself. Your fat. Keep your distance if possible. . Make sure to have several encounters. Scopes, guns, boots and other tactical stuff in-between. The heaviest I have found without casting my own is 265 gr. They made it to a small hunting cabin but went to find some firewood outside and upon opening the door, the bear was going to come in! When Jeff Newville faced his moment of truth with the grizzly, he barely had time to fire his revolver. has a well-deserved reputation as a charge-stopper. However, as far as stopping power on even the largest grizzly bear, it delivers enough energy to get the job done. I was driving along an overland trail, about to cross a small creek and pop back out onto the beach of our lake. 3) Self defense from a bear attack with a pistol is a cautionary tale at best, correct? I had also noticed that your post of 13:49 was damned good. They have not released their data, but they found handguns to be 84% effective against bears, surprisingly, more effective than long guns. Now that you mention it, my wife was the one that told me Right after asking if the life insurance was up to date, It might have continued on to hit the spine, resulting in the instant collapse of the bear.. I found the account as I was searching for bear attacks where pistols had been used as a defensive measure. I am skeptical. The result, of course, was the .50 Alaskan. WTF are you doing using a holster you are not absolutely certain how to operate? And whatever you do, never try to approach or touch a dead bear. The larger the gun, and to some extent, the longer the barrel, the less felt recoil and muzzle flip you will experience. CRIME AND WILD ANIMALS LIKE WHEEL OF FORTUNE SPIN, NEVER KNOW WHEN IT WILL STOP ON YOUR NUMBER. And sometimes folks can save themselves with a handgun. Your cigarettes. Maybe you should pay more attention to the world around you and have a little less Tude with everyone. After all, I hadnt yet read any words from Hank, so I had no reason to do so at the time. Thoughtful, knowledgeable, unusual, and well-written. As Nelson has seen in bear defense training, many shooters have cycling issues with the 10mm due to the limp-wrist syndrome, something that isnt an issue with a revolver and is the last thing you want to happen during a bear charge. However, using a more powerful cartridge such as the .44 Magnum is recommended to ensure quick and humane kills. .300 Remington Ultra Magnum (180gr Nosler Partition at 3,243fps)(4,202 ft lbs): 25.7 For big bear defense handguns, the Smith & Wesson 629 is hard to beat. For example, I said Ive made lower-48 black bears leave my campsites a lot more than 29 times just by sounding irritated. They are lucky to have survived given they left their primary defensive weapon in a tree! I looked in the direction of Reed only to once again see the bear charging at me. I carry both, with bear spray on my left side and a .44 on my right, so IF the bear spray fails Im not completely f-ed. I could eat a can of alphabet soup and shit out a smarter statement than what you posted !!! American Buffalo Knife and Tool Co. is adding to its line of Roper Knives with the new Sunset Series Tumble Weed. You criticize Dean for his 30 cases, all of which are sourced, yet you flat out refuse to source your own claims. If Im on my ATV my rifle stays in your typical V shaped rifle mount that attaches to my front rack, retained by rubber straps. Nelson killed one of his charging grizzlies with a .454 Casull, which he says is one of his favorite choices for bear defense. Lessons learned . I carry a 6 inch Redhawk with 325 grain hard cast lead handloads when I go to Grizzly country. Never had to shoot a bear with it, and hope it stays that way, but pretty confident it will do the trick if needed. https://www.nrafamily.org/articles/2017/7/6/handguns-for-defense-in-bear-country/ Go outside and smoke a cigarette or something. Many bear attacks happen in brush where a shorter draw is preferable. It was a statement that very few of us are in the far north, so very few of us are in the far-north areas where black bears are so much bigger, aggressive, and dangerous. So be sure to keep an eye on the animal until it is definitely dead. They almost never attack . And those rifleslike the Marlin 1894 or Ruger 77/44are lightweight, compact, and ideal for hound. This stopped many tigers that had attacked the hunters riding atop elephants in India! FOLKS AT BUFFALO BORE AND HORNADY PARTICULARLY FRIENDLY, KNOWLEDGEABLE AND HAPPY TO HELP. Dude you should stop before you have a heart attack. There is no definitive answer to this question as different bears will respond differently to various types of bullets. However, Ive learned a few things. Then you have to get on target which is easier with a shorter, lighter gun. For animals, I always get concentrated-stream types. Oddly enough, that same 158 grain LRN bullet is prone to through and through on people. Caliber: .44 Magnum. These are the most vulnerable areas on a bear. As the bear charge drill in his course demonstrates, the average bear attack will happen at 50 yards or less with an 800-pound animal moving at 30 mph. (THIS IS A SEPARATE SUBJECT. Get a closer look at the Smith & Wesson Model 350, the latest addition to our #SundayGunday series. Ive watched, while working out, flossing, but never sittingI dont sit while I watch TVpretty much every documentary on bears ever shown, including the one on crazy, brave, brilliant, dead Timothy Treadwell. Let's look at those assumptions a bit closer in the following table. Someone who hates you. Admit that you made a mistake, Hank, and that you were wrong, and apologize. The second and third time I used bear spray was against overly aggressive dogs. LAST TIME CALLED BUFFALO BORE GOT THE OWNER AND MUCH TALK AND HELP ON CARBINE AND PISTOL ROUNDS NEEDED FOR A SITUATION SINCE I AM ARMED ESCORT FOR LIVING. Even us mortal men can keep at it after being shot many times with small rounds, let alone a grizzly.. Not a 12 guage with 00 buck at close range, in the face. My uncle Dale dropped a charging sow with a neck shot at the same distance with a s&w 629. Thats why. Above the lower 48 states, as you get farther and farther north, black bears do get bigger and bigger, more and more aggressive, and more and more dangerous, and you just might have to shoot one. It dispels the notion that pistols are useless as a defense. Even the very biggest brown bears are 1,500 pounds. I havent seen anyone advocate using a pistol as an offensive weapon for bears in this thread, or in the article, it is specifically about using a pistol as a defensive weapon on a charging bear. Yes you do want a magnum. And you actually said this:handguns are the best. A female grizzly will do almost anything to protect her cubs. I see youre suddenly changing from Jesse Pinkman language to an exact imitation of Donald Trump-tweet language.Why? Bear will win every time. Im not criticizing him for that, but he didnt say it was his research. These are all factors that need to be considered when choosing a caliber for a serious and serviceable bear defense firearm. Yet, they have no idea what it feels like to pull the trigger much less shoot that pistol. He or she could have one of the following, a 44 or larger with at least 300 grain flat nose, or a 12 guage shorty with 00 buck or a Brennicke slug. You still need to know how to use it effectively in order to maximize its potential. People arent buying snubbies in big calibers for this kind of situation any more than theyre buying large knives because they want to join that one guy who actually did kill a grizzly with a Ka-Bar. 5. A 44 mag with hard cast will travel a long ways through meat and bone if youre up close. However, if you are dealing with an especially large or aggressive bear, you may need something more powerful. Honestly cant remember ever having an issue taking grizz with a 44 mag (Ruger super Blackhawk) . So yes, I did do my homework before opening my big mouth. As with anything, the devil is in the details. Our Sitemap. Holy shit I cant stop laughing. Since the bear usually knows where you are long before you are aware of the bear, your reaction time may be considerably less than 4.5 seconds. Large caliber handgun ammunition is expensive. 10 BEST PADDLE BOARD AND KAYAK COMBOS 2023 WITH BUYING GUIDE, Grizzly 300 Grain Cast lead bullet wide flat nose, Buffalo Bore 300-grain hard cast flat nose bullet, Buffalo Bore 300 grain jacketed flat nose. But whenever he's in an area with a serious and credible grizzly threat, he likes his 12-gauge shotgun loaded with slugs. As for his own writing, yeah, I sure do criticize it. For many backwoods trekkers, hunters, and homesteaders the 44 mag is the mainstay of their bear defense. Keep in mind that you might need a Magnum load to propel a heavy bullet to a decent velocity. Scotty, or Cisco or whatever his current intertube name is; I believe may be afflicted with the same disability as my unfortunate nephew. His raging confrontational writing style that relies upon fabricated facts, is so close to his that I wouldnt be surprised if it was revealed that he indeed is actually my nephew. Stay safe out there! of energy from the muzzle. To my surprise, the buckle was actually a snap and the strap peeled away. Wow dude, for real? Like the Spartans xiphos blade, the handgun is a much shorter secondary weapon intended for up-close-and-personal encounters. I DO GET THAT:) I think akgunner wrote a comment below the article which is more helpful than the article itself. of energy, while 1,000 ft/lbs is considered the minimum for a bear hunting gun. Im certain this is the most butthurt Ive made anyone on this website since that crazed lefty threatened to sue me. Along with delivered energy, we must also consider bullet weight and velocity. Never needed it, but I remember he let me shoot it, almost knocked me over! I LIVE IN COLORADO BETWEEN CRAIG, CO AND BAGGS, WY. As stated by Marshall and Sanow in Stopping Power, As a general trend, and all else being equal, stopping power increases as the size of the recovered bullet increases., In addition, their table Caliber Comparison on page 335 shows a significant advantage for .45 ACP over .38.special. People claim there are multiple instances where people with pistols failed to stop the attack and/or kill the bear. Should be easy to find if they are out there. Elmer Keith developed it to hunt AK Brown bears. 2. As soon as I rounded the corner I spotted a probably 900lb brown bear, not barely 20yds away. photo from thetruthaboutguns.com. Among firearms platforms, a rifle delivers more energy and is effective to greater distances, making it the first choice. of energy at the muzzle. It was used 12 times. There is no doubt in my mind that the .44 magnum cartridge is a viable choice as a bear defense gun. The number of large caliber rifle rounds that came out of that bastard were truly frightening. Finally, always remember that proper shot placement is key when using 44 mag ammo for bear defense. akgunners command of language, his clarity of thought, and his thinking were just superb today. Why the Alaskan was designed as a snubbie? Feel free to reach out to us or read our affiliate disclosure and privacy policy. Ruger just took a Super Redhawk and cut the barrel even with the frame extension. Several folks have even successfully killed bears with a 9mm. AT 1.82 per round, I can afford to go to the range to hone my skills. Hes in a medical field, Id really like to know if he noticed any hearing damage after 4-5 rounds of *big boom*. Down in the article a little ways Paco talks about his bear kill. Any dolls at all? We made a simulated bear and shot it with a Desert Eagle! Yes, the 7mm Remington Magnum is A GOOD CHOICE for grizzly or brown bear hunting, under average conditions, from a mid-range distance, with a medium grain expanding bullet, and with correct shot placement. According to Hornady's data, the XTP bullets from a 7.5-inch barrel clock at 1350 fps and generate . When you consider the other factors involved, the 44-magnum may even be a better choice for some than the larger and more powerful calibers. Kim had a Glock model 20 10 mm pistol with him. Im pretty sure, he would say, the gun is only as good as the person handling it. Ticks. Its similar to the one my cousin uses. Doug shot the bear and stopped the attack. Smith & Wesson. . Polar bear attacks are expected there, and tourists are not allowed unless they carry a high powered firearm. test, none of us were looking forward to running the S&W 329 PD with the Hornady 240-grain JHP loads I had brought along. Stopping power in a handgun cartridge is measured in numerous ways. LOL . COPYRIGHT 2021, THETRUTHABOUTGUNS.COM. ONE DEAD HIKER EMPTIED .38 IN HIM AND CAN SEE HOW WELL THAT WORKED. Despite NGs statement about black bears normally running when confronted by a human, do not bet your life on it! . The bears run in and out of the visual field of the video camera. .45-70 GovernmentFirst adopted by the U.S. military in 1873, the .45-70 Government has been one of the longest-standing big-game cartridges of all time. . I CARRY BEAR SPRAY FOR DOGS NOT BEARS. And by your TV remark, I guess youre a big fan of getting a fat ass by sitting around and watching the box instead of using TV as a tool to make yourself healthy, capable, and strong. But while our hands were fresh we shot the revolver first. I am thinking I would allways have a friend with me to watch my back, if indeed I was to be in a situation of a bear encroachment. My hunting friend swears by his Ruger Red Hawk Alaskan. here: Live survive love laugh and be happy, not screaming in terror before dying in pain, 7mm Remington Magnum (168gr Nosler AccuBond LR at 2,880fps): 19.6 I could not figure out how it held the gun in place, so I grabbed the buckle and attempted to rip it off. It stretched from the peak of the cabin to the ground. Im thankful that Ive never had to defend myself against anything but an overly aggressive dog. The minimum caliber for black bear is .30-06 Springfield. The comparative recoil data shows the difference between our chosen calibers. We would like to show you a description here but the site won't allow us. Anyone else? Not at all. Grizzly bears enter a state of hyperphagia in the fall, a condition that provokes gluttony in preparation for winter hibernation. All of that being said, in my past 4 years in Alaska, you know how many times Ive been attacked by a bear? The bear was just as startled as I. Id like to see Boddingtons sources for hundreds of attacks. Modern bears remained top predators thanks to evolution weeding out the bears that dropped faster due to serious injury. Talk about stopping power. The latest way appears to be an app called CamoSpace, designed specifically for members of the hunting community. Because a bear will suffer irreversible and irreparable damage to its heart, lungs, spine, and brain if it is shot, the only way to kill it is to shoot it so that it can be killed. Many laud the .44 Magnum as real bear medicine, and it's got plenty of power for a bear defense handgunas long as you remember that it's still not a rifle. You have entered an incorrect email address! I am not looking to go toe to toe with a Grizzly, but if I am out bow hunting or have set down my rifle to gut a deer it is far better to have a handgun that will effectively penetrate a large animal than to scramble for my rifle if I get charged. Two or three times, he never replied, I looked everywhere, no bear, as I turned and looked behind me, ( I was setting in a camp chair) I was eye to eye with a big Boar Grizzly coming in fast, ( Luckily he wasnt charging yet) I looked him in the Eye, he was not stopping! That might be the reason. A handgun is worn on your person, however, and is invaluable because it stays with you, whether youre answering natures call or stopping to field dress a game animal. I bothered to read the articles about last weeks the bear attack in Florida, unlike you. You should be using slugs, and not just your average deer slug but hot ones, and you can forget about buckshot. Can a 44 Magnum kill a bear? of energy, and it takes a big grizzly to weigh 1,000 pounds. Click bait makes me so mad I wish I had a .44 magnum! To give folks working in dangerous animal country a very portable self defense tool. For example the venerable .38 Special, 158 grain load exits a four-inch barrel at something like 950 fps which isnt enough velocity to reliably cause deep, catastrophic damage in a large, tough animal. Are you melting snowflake? I recommend training and study before using. It immediately blew enough of it back in my own face that had it been a defensive use, it would have made matters worse. WHEN IN HOUSE CHEST RIG ALWAYS ON AND PISTOL UNDER PILLOW AT NIGHT. I have always acknowledged your educational and army background and qualifications when Ive criticized you. Some of them are like a fog. of energy. 2 (90-5-5) alloy and size them to .430. But they dont have sense enough to get out of the way of a truck. Ive also bothered to read Weingartens stuff for years. Although I seldom agreed with Jeff Cooper he was right when he said that if you use a handgun as an offensive weapon its tantamount to committing suicide no matter what the caliber. Make sure to practice with your chosen firearm beforehand, and always check local regulations when traveling in bear country. Think about it. Presumably he removed it when they started cleaning the moose, which is probably the worst time to do so. Buffalo Bore produces several loads for the .50 Alaskan, including a 450-grain bullet that delivers a whopping 4,400 ft.-lbs. GO FIGURE. Craig Boddingtons new book dispels the myth that carrying a handgun in big bear country is effective in stopping a bear. Thanks for visiting eatingthewild.com. .458 Winchester Magnum (500gr Hornady DGX at 2,140fps)(has 5083.36 ft lbs): 70.0 Bear spray is worthless Ive used it three times. Value. They know theyre probably going to wind up underneath any grizzly that charges, shot or not. Best thing in the world? of energy at 1550 fps, which is more than double that of the 10mm and four times more energy than the 9mm. Aim for the head or heart if possible. Take your time in selecting a shot and make sure to take into account distance, windage, and elevation. I forgot to mention it, and you should get credit where credit is due. WE HAVE WOLVES, MTN LIONS AND BEARS APLENTY AROUND MY ELK CAMP. Granted, the stopping power of any pistol is low, but the nonsense in your post about the .38 vs .45 makes everything else you say not credible. 2017 by Dean. Bears, including grizzlies, have been killed with 22 long rifles. Take a deep breath and realize this is an anonymous Internet forum. FLORIDA IN WINTER AND HAVE USED IT ON SEVERAL PIT BULLS AFTER ME AND NOT THAT IMPRESSED, FIGURE PISSED OFF BEAR 100 X PIT BULL SO NO THANKS. The 44 magnum is almost unspeakably more powerful than the 22 rimfire, so of course it will kill a bear. My cousin lives in AK and Ive helped him dress a bear. Always remember to check local regulations regarding firearms when traveling in bear country. In some cases, it may not even penetrate the bear's thick hide. He took that bear with his Stalker..and a great ad for that gun was a pic of Larry standing and facing the end wall of the cabin after the storm, with the bear mounted flat on the wall. No problem. I wonder what Larry Kelly would have to say about the negative talk here about the Magnaport Stalker handguns that his company builtand he took to Alaska and the African continent to do his testing with it way back in the late 70s or 80s. Need to read Elmer Keiths accounts of animal attacks in Hell, I was there. If only those murderous hunters had been carrying bear spray, that poor bear would still be alive. You have to do more than say there are books out there, you have to read em. For more information on how to protect yourself from bears, visit the website of your local hunting or outdoors store. A reliable Winchester pump-action shotgun and Brenneke Black Magic Magnum slugs. Considered by many to be the minimum for big bear defense rounds, the .44 Remington Magnum was first introduced in 1955 for revolvers and gained widespread popularity in the 1970s thanks to Dirty Harry. Favorites include, from top, an S&W in .44 Mag, a Dan Wesson in .445 SuperMag and a single-action Ruger chambered in .41 Magnum. The 44 magnum does deliver less energy on target than the other calibers in our comparison tables. At this kind of range the accuracy of the longer barrel doesnt much matter nor does the penetration, which doesnt much matter anyway. Good on him for having the clarity of mind to make such a shot, and for having the appropriate ammo in an appropriate caliber such that it could actually travel through a large bear and disrupt the spine and cause such a necessary instantaneous stop. Over the decades, several cartridges have proved themselves as worthy against the nastiest bears North America has to offer. Great story. Hes seen a large grizzly remain upright and functional for 90 seconds to 2 minutes after taking a fatal chest shot. Why, oh why, wasnt that gun on someones hip? Im referring to the Trending now BS. The 9mm can kill bears but is considered underpowered by experienced woodsmen. My Uncle Allen used a 12gauge (rifled slug) center mass at 30 feet. You have a bone to pick with Dean and your bias is showing thru. It is easy to see that the 44 Magnum is far from being the most powerful handgun in the world. statement Ive made people really understand what to do about bears? I scanned the far shore to see if it was a nice one, maybe I would take it, I didnt see it, so I asked him where? .454 Casull Developed by Dick Casull and Jack Fulmer in 1957, the .454 Casull is a dangerous game hunters dream come true. I dont look for bear but if one came my way I am ready. But how much time have you spent in the far northern woods so far in your life?. A charging grizzly bear can reach speeds of 35 mph an hour for short distances and their acceleration rate is phenomenal. Depends on what type of bear. 44 mag ammo for bear can be a life-saving tool, but only if it is used correctly. The cartridge was used to thwart attacks from black bear, brown bear, grizzly, and even a Kodiak Bear. I had no expectation that the pistol would kill the bear. So, people are mauled by bears. Tyler Freel A 12 gauge's effectiveness can vary tremendously based on the ammunition used. The 44 magnum is no exception. Mostly considered a revolver cartridge, the .44 Magnum is often chambered in rifles. The black bear is the only animal in the continental U.S. that can provide the average hunter a reasonably accessible opportunity to hunt dangerous game - game with fangs and claws rather than horns and hooves. .. However, most bear encounters are under less than perfect conditions. After all your names not Hank. of energy, while the 10mm has about 728 ft.-lbs., both with a 180-grain Buffalo Bore bullet. .45-70 Government (405gr SP at 1,330fps)(1,590 ft lbs): 35.2 Based on the .375 H&H, the .338 will send a 300-grain Barnes bullet out the barrel at 2500 fps with a devastating 4,100 ft.-lbs. Admit that you were wrong and apologize. He had a long explanation for why this happens, which I boiled down to two sentences above. This attack makes29 pistol defenses against bears that I have found. But I can count em well enough to know it was a lot more than the tiny sample of 29 that he cherry-picked to scare you. The hunters violated the most basic safety rule when cleaning game to pack out. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. But bears are all-natural and organic, and everybody knows that anything that is all-natural and organic is safe and good for your health, right? So, show us the instances that will change the percentages. 1. He said it was his hunting partners gun. That means having the right gear, and knowing how to use it. If I was in the wilderness thered be a gun on me at all times. No. They dont. My state used to require a class and a license to buy pepper spray, and I lived there, so I took the class. Dont know if anyone else remembers his encounter in Alaska with a grizzthat had been following him and a guide in a bad storm. It depends on the situation, as well as the type of bear in question. The 10mm is also coming into popularity because of capacity. .30-06 Springfield (180gr Nosler Partition at 2,750fps): 21.8 No joke, a full house 44 Mag in a rifle kicks. A well placed shot from a .44 Magnum will penetrate both shoulders of a black bear with ease.